Sunday, March 18, 2018

Putting words in his mouth …

… Why do we love to quote (and misquote) Albert Einstein? | Aeon Essays. (Hat tip, Rus Bowden.)

… consider a statement prominently attributed to Einstein in the concluding section of a current British Museum exhibition on religion, ‘Living with Gods’: ‘The most beautiful and profound experience is the sensation of the mystical. It is the sower of all true science.’ Absent from The Ultimate Quotable Einstein, it seems to have been derived in the decades after Einstein’s death from the following comment, in his handwriting, spoken by him in 1932 for a recording issued by the German League for Human Rights. Translated from Einstein’s original German it reads: ‘The most beautiful and profound experience is the feeling of mystery. It underlies religion as well as all deeper aspirations in art and science.’ Note the most significant modification: ‘mystery’ in 1932 has become ‘mystical’ by 2018.
Attaching oneself to authority is a nice way of avoiding having to think for yourself.  As Aquinas pointed out, the weakest form of argument is the argument from authority. Of course, he immediately cited  the authority of Boethius in support of his assertion (I somehow think the irony was not lost on him).

No comments:

Post a Comment